To Be Or Not To Be Ecstatic

Team Haider, director Vishal Bhardwaj and Amrita Pandey, VP & Head, Marketing and Distribution, Studios, Disney India in conversation with team Box Office India

Box Office India (BOI): Are you happy now?

Vishal Bhardwaj (VB): Yes, I am very happy.

BOI: Are you satisfied with the film’s reviews and its collections?

VB: I attribute this reaction to Maqbool. All my friends in the industry and even people who don’t like my kind of cinema have praised Haider.

BOI: What did you do differently this time?

VB: Nothing, really. I did the same thing. (Laughs)

BOI: Do you think the audience has grown?

VB: No, I think I have grown.

BOI: When UTV decided to back Haider, a lot of people asked you whether it was the right decision.

Amrita Pandey (AP): Did they? Who were these people? I want to know. (Laughs)

BOI: How does it feel now?

AP: It’s a great feeling. We are all very happy. We have worked with Vishal so many times…

VB: Yes, I have made eight films, of which four were with UTV.

AP: I remember it was Dussera and we were talking about the script and what he had done with the film. He has taken this film several notches higher. I remember how excited I was after seeing the first few scenes he had shot.

BOI: You had said it was very difficult for UTV to come on board for a film like Haider. Why did you say that?

AP: Did I say that? I don’t think so. (Laughs) I think it was a very natural progression for us.

VB: Yeah, during the very first narration, Sid (Siddharth Roy Kapur), Ronnie (Screwvala) and Amrita agreed.

AP: We met for the first time in July and began rolling during Dussera.

BOI: Has the result exceeded your expectations?

AP: The unanimous response has been overwhelmingly positive. We all loved it and we knew that people like us would love it. The amazing thing is that everyone in the industry loved the film.

BOI: Vishal, what was it about Shahid Kapoor that made you cast him in the lead role?

VB: Many things. First, he wanted to do a film with me and had been talking to me about it for the last 18 months. I wanted to take a star who wouldn’t charge money and who would erase that blot ki film acchi hai par sasti honi chahiye. I had been hearing that for a long time and was fed up with it. So that was the main reason. Next, I wanted someone who would give a hundred-per cent commitment. And I wanted him to go bald and he agreed to everything. I think Shahid is a very good actor and is, in fact, the best actor in his age group.

BOI: For any actor who portrays the role of Hamlet, ‘to be or not to be’ is the most important scene. How difficult was it for you and Shahid to execute that scene?

VB: The tough part was writing the scene, baaki execute karna toh uske writing mein already tha hi. There were many options to ‘to be or not to be’, and we used many variations in the film, which we retained. Like, hum hain ki hum hain nahi, hai ke hain nahi and main hoon ke hoon nahi… But main rahoon ki main nahi was the closest. So execution was not as big a challenge as writing was. There was a poetic rendition in it, which we made Shahid aware of during our preparation.

BOI: Was it difficult to convince Tabu to play Shahid’s mother?

VB: Yes. And thank God she was convinced. Now she too must be thanking God that she agreed to do it because she has been receiving much acclaim. In their review, The New York Times said the film should have been called Ghazala. That’s the biggest compliment an actor can get.

BOI: How did you convince her?

VB: Actually I didn’t have a choice. Mere paas koi aur tha nahi and, more importantly, she was able to see Gertrude’s character. But she was also wondering how she would play the role of Shahid’s mother because Shahid started his career very early and he has been around a while. The problem is, in India, we tend to categorise actors that once you play a mother, you always get roles like that. We tend to make fun of people, saying tumne Shahid ki maa ka role play kiya hai. One day, she told me that ab toh bas, Shah Rukh ki mother ka role play karna reh gaya hai. (Laughs)

We argued so much over this that we even stopped talking to each other for a few days. But once we calmed down, I thought I shouldn’t let my ego get in the way of my work. So I went back to her and said, ‘Look at the role of Ghazala, not as Shahid’s mother but as the character Gertrude, because Shahid will not look like Shahid Kapoor. It won’t seem as though this is Shahid Kapoor. He will be like any other character, he will be like Haider. I gave her one more option, to charge me as much as she wanted.

BOI: What was her response when she saw it?

VB: She didn’t like it, initially. I think that’s her way of experiencing catharsis. Every actor has their own ways. For instance, Kay Kay didn’t like himself on screen either. So I thought maybe all the actors have this method. Pehle apne aap ko napasand kar lo phir apni taarefein suno.

BOI: Your have portrayed the Oedipus complex very blatantly in the film. Did Tabu have any apprehensions with those scenes?

VB: No. In fact, these were the key things that attracted her to the role!

BOI: How did the Censor Board react to it?

VB: They didn’t have any objections. I was expecting them to say something, especially the scene where the mother kisses the son. But it was done in such a natural way that it didnt seem replusive at all. When we were shooting, I did have my apprehensions and I wondered how that scene would look eventually. But the way Tabu managed to create this beautiful, invisible vibe in that scene that you can’t pinpoint why it does not look repulsive.

BOI: What was UTV’s reaction when they saw the film?

VB: We were very happy. It exceeded our expectations. It was like magic and we were blown away when we watched it.

BOI: Were you sure the film would do well?

VB: A week earlier, we were wondering whether to show it to the industry or not. At that stage, as a director, you lose perspective and you look through the eyes of other people. But I was not in favour of showing it. I thought waise bhi bahut mazaak udta hai, so there is no point in screening the film earlier. But Sid and Amrita were both so confident. One day, Sid called me and he, Amrita and I were on a conference call. I was still apprehensive, so they said we should show it to the audience and go all out on the front foot and own this film, and be proud of it. Jisko acchi lagegi, it’s good, and even if they speak ill of it, we shouldn’t care. That’s when I realised I was the one behaving like a producer and they were behaving like a director. So I called Sid and told him that directors usually want to show their films to people and like to get praised. Praise hi milta hai, gaali toh milti nahi. So I told him that it was his call, and if he wanted to show the film, we should start that day itself. It was shown and appreciated by fellow filmmakers.

BOI: Amrita, why did you decide to back the film and what made you release it alongside Bang Bang?

AP: When we got the film, there was a narration and we loved it. We watched a few shots which he had shot of the first half, because they had completed the autmn schedule of the film. We were completely blown away. I think our sensibilities were the same and our chemistry matched. So we were all very confident. So we met towards the release, when we had announced Phantom, and we were not sure when to release but we were sure we wanted a strong weekend. We thought there could be no better day than this weekend because it was a five-day weekend. It was the best weekend of the year and the longest weekend before Diwali. So we all felt we should go for it.

BOI: You started promoting the film very early.

AP: Yes, we did. We did that because Vishal was travelling.

VB: And Shahid was also shooting.

AP: We cracked such a good trailer that we felt we should make the most of it. At that time, I remember, there was a trailer releasing every week, but we were confident. Moreover, Vishal was travelling a little later and we wanted Vishal and Shahid for the launch. So we launched the trailer on July 7. The trade asked us why we were launching the trailer so early and pointed out that we did not need such a long run-up for this film. But we went ahead anyway. We decided to go with our gut and the decision worked in our favour as the songs in the trailer picked up well with the audience.

BOI: Vishal, Amrita told us, you went to London to do the background score?

VB: I have been trying to do that all my life. By the time a film reaches post, the budget is over and going to London is expensive, you know. So, this time, I set aside a sum from the budget just like I did for the music. Since I am a music composer, I know budgets and I told my production guys I needed the money for my songs and that I would be doing those songs in the post. I didn’t tell them I needed it for background score because then they would have said ‘no’. So, I had to lie to my own production guy!

BOI: You knew the background score for this film was very important.

VB: It’s important for every film. I have been trying to achieve this kind of background score for a long time. It’s a special term called ‘quartet’, where you have four musicians, any four musicians.

Usually, in classic terms, a quartet comprises four strings, which could be two violins, one viola and one cello but one can include only four musicians. It’s a very old, classic form. Either you go with a harmony orchestra, like, an 80-piece orchestra, which many have done, like Dhoom 3 did a Philharmonic Orchestra. But, when I watched these films as a music composer, it did not stand out. I felt the key lay in the opposite direction. I wanted to go as minimalistic as possible and focus more on textures, which we have stopped doing because we need so much underlining in our music that we have started using a lot of rhythm, a lot of music and a lot of musicians. That’s why I took that other route.

I did the same thing with Maachis. In those days, the more violins you used in a song, the bigger your reputation as a composer. But I went in the opposite direction. We worked on textures. Like, in Haider, most of the time there is a voice humming, and that voice is of a Western singer. I told her I wanted it to sound like wind passing through bamboos, not a shrinking voice. That’s how we textured it.

In London, I could only afford one shift and one shift for them is only three hours long. But we hired possibly the best musicians in the world. They are super-expensive but the best. So I did only one three-hour shift in London and, during those three hours, we recorded 24 minutes of music. According to their calculations, one can record eight minutes of music in an hour. They are the best musicians, the London Symphony Orchestra. I believe these small things made a big difference to the songs of the film.

Box Office India
Collection Chart
As on 17th November, 2017
Qarib Qarib Singlle111.20CR11.20CR
Shaadi Mein Zaroor Aana16.14CR6.14CR
The House Next Door192.43LK92.43LK
Mera Bura Saaya108.2K08.2K

Featured Video

Most Viewed Articles


Last 7 Days

Last 30 Days


Box Office India's Twitter avatar
Box Office India

#Padmavati has been certified 12A by British censors for 2D and 3D.

Box Office India's Twitter avatar
Box Office India

Story writer #KamnaChandra of #QaribQaribSinglle throws light on various significant people involved in the film ma…



This Week’s Issue

Trade Gup

  • What is Rajkumar Hirani’s next sequel?
  • Vishal Bhardwaj to have three releases in 2018
  • Phantom to clash with Reliance Phantom
  • Zee to acquire UTV Movies
  • Akshay Kumar, Arshad Warsi in Jolly LLB 3

In Conversation

  • A M Turaz weaves poetry into his lyrics for Padmavati
  • Laxmi Raai makes her Bollywood debut with her 50th film, Julie2
  • SVF’s Mahendra Soni breaks a record for Amazon Obhijaan
  • Milind Rao on The House Next Door and his love for horror
  • Guru Randhawa hits a high note with Ban ja tu meri rani
  • Freewheeling with Sidharth Malhotra after Ittefaq

Straight News

  • Bhutiani is jury member at Munich fest
  • Prashantt Guptha to reprise Rafi classic
  • Fox, Abundantia to make P Gopichand biopic
  • Karan Johar’s short film to roll soon


  • When editing, I never direct, says Chandan Arora
  • For Eeshit Narain, it all started over a cup of tea…
  • I love the modern version of my script: Kamna Chandra
  • It was very personal for me, admits Ghazal Dhaliwal