Unidentical Twins

It is one of the most striking ironies of our times – the last remaining bastion of communist philosophy and politics in the world, China, has risen to the status of global superpower by essentially playing out of the capitalistic playbook. And this ideological flip-flop is often justified by quoting those famous words of the very powerful and influential Chinese leader, Deng Xiaoping: It doesn’t matter if a cat is black or white, as long as it catches mice
A similar sentiment is often expressed during cricket match commentaries, especially when a batsman scores some fortuitous runs through an edged shot or from overthrows: It doesn’t matter how they come, as long as they come!t is one of the most striking ironies of our times – the last remaining bastion of communist philosophy and politics in the world, China, has risen to the status of global superpower by essentially playing out of the capitalistic playbook. And this ideological flip-flop is often justified by quoting those famous words of the very powerful and influential Chinese leader, Deng Xiaoping: It doesn’t matter if a cat is black or white, as long as it catches mice.

However, while the owner of a rodent-free house or the captain of a victorious cricket team may no longer be interested in the means that made their happy ending possible, learning from the path to past successes can be interesting and rewarding for those hoping to replicate the same. That is especially true of a risk-fraught domain like filmmaking, where even the smallest advantage one can derive from studying past precedent is most welcome.

In that spirit, this week, we are examining two recent releases that succeeded at the box office but that sit at opposite ends of Hindi cinema’s narrative spectrum.

Judwaa 2 is the quintessential commercial ‘masala’ film – a veteran director who has almost written the rule book on the genre, an A-league male lead and two glamorous leading ladies, glossy overseas locales, crowd-pleasing music and a storyline that promises you accessible comic entertainment. Newton, on the other hand, is the archetypical ‘low-budget-high-concept’ film – an accomplished actor rather than a commercial star as main lead, a second-time director who debuted with an even ‘smaller’ film, a narrative that is designed to provoke thought rather than cater to the lowest common denominator and an emphasis on realism in production values.    

Of course, with Judwaa 2’s numbers being in multiples of Netwon’s score, you cannot really compare the collections of the two films in absolute terms and the objective of this note is not to get into the relative merits of the two films. Rather, our goal in analysing the collections data of both films is to see how similar – or not – is the box office trajectory of a ‘big, commercial’ film vis-à-vis a ‘small, content-oriented’ movie.

Take a look at the table below:

ComparatorJudwaa 2Newton
Property Type   
Contribution Of Multiplexes8099.5
Contribution Of Single Screens200.5
Territorial Contribution  
Mumbai28.932.69
Delhi-UP22.3923.84
East Punjab9.113.36
CP5.494.69
CI4.253.95
Rajasthan6.134.46
Nizam5.263.71
Mysore5.086.13
West Bengal6.144.9
Bihar-Jharkhand3.760.72
Assam1.050.34
Orissa1.170.29
TNK1.230.91
Contribution of Different Time Spans  
First Day11.914.09
First Weekend43.2718.32
First Week71.7856.44
Second Week19.6929.87
Third Week7.877.65
Post Week 30.756.02

All figures – Percentage of lifetime domestic collections of respective films

The compilation above compares the collections break-up of each film from three different viewpoints – the nature of the exhibition platform (multiplex or single screen), the geographical territory and key time milestones.

To summarise the key insights: 

Virtually all of Netwon’s collections came from multiplex properties. While multiplexes were the dominant contributor for Judwaa 2 too, the role of single-screen properties cannot be overlooked. To put things in perspective: in absolute terms, Judwaa 2’s single-screen revenues were more than Netwon’s entire box-office tally. So while single screens may have ceded considerable ground to multiplexes, they are by no means irrelevant, especially for commercial cinema.

Surprisingly, the variation in the contribution of different distribution territories to each film’s kitty isn’t as wide as one would expect it to be. The top three territories for both films are identical and, by and large, there is a fair degree of correlation in the two sets of numbers. That would imply that there is a high degree of stability in the relative importance of each territory to the national box office, irrespective of the nature of the film.

Perhaps the most significant divergence between the two trajectories is seen in the time milestones comparison. Judwaa 2 made more than 10 per cent of its lifetime collections on its very first day in theatres, while Newton made just about 4 per cent. Conversely, less than 1 per cent of Judwaa 2’s tally accrued after 3 weeks at the box office, while Newton collected a decent 6 per cent in the same time span. Each film, therefore, conforms to the typical pattern that successful films in both categories display – a big opening and front-ending of collections for the commercial blockbusters, compared to a modest opening that grows with positive word-of-mouth and steady accumulation of collections over a long theatrical run for content-led films.

Above all, this study emphasises how important it is to truly understand the nature of one’s film when planning its release strategy. While the wishlist may be to open wide and quickly mop up as much moolah as you can, it is rarely possible – even advisable – for every film to attempt do so. The race to the finishing line, especially for the smaller films, may be more a steady marathon than a frantic sprint… and it is critical that one understands that before setting off from the starting block.

In other words – and it is only fair that a note that began with a feline reference should conclude with one – there are more ways to skin the box office cat than one!

Nitin Tej Ahuja
Collection Chart
As on 17th November, 2017
FilmsWeekWeeklyTotal
Qarib Qarib Singlle111.20CR11.20CR
Shaadi Mein Zaroor Aana16.14CR6.14CR
The House Next Door192.43LK92.43LK
Mera Bura Saaya108.2K08.2K
Safe101.01K01.01K
Maheruh112K12K
More

Featured Video

Most Viewed Articles

Today

Last 7 Days

Last 30 Days

Twitter

Box Office India's Twitter avatar
Box Office India
@boxofficeindia

Dialogue writer #GazalDhaliwal of #QaribQaribSinglle reveals her future projects, her inspiration behind her work a… t.co/2J4RQtaJHz

Box Office India's Twitter avatar
Box Office India
@boxofficeindia

#Padmavati has been certified 12A by British censors for 2D and 3D.

Facebook

Instagram

This Week’s Issue

Trade Gup

  • What is Rajkumar Hirani’s next sequel?
  • Vishal Bhardwaj to have three releases in 2018
  • Phantom to clash with Reliance Phantom
  • Zee to acquire UTV Movies
  • Akshay Kumar, Arshad Warsi in Jolly LLB 3

In Conversation

  • A M Turaz weaves poetry into his lyrics for Padmavati
  • Laxmi Raai makes her Bollywood debut with her 50th film, Julie2
  • SVF’s Mahendra Soni breaks a record for Amazon Obhijaan
  • Milind Rao on The House Next Door and his love for horror
  • Guru Randhawa hits a high note with Ban ja tu meri rani
  • Freewheeling with Sidharth Malhotra after Ittefaq

Straight News

  • Bhutiani is jury member at Munich fest
  • Prashantt Guptha to reprise Rafi classic
  • Fox, Abundantia to make P Gopichand biopic
  • Karan Johar’s short film to roll soon

Spotlight

  • When editing, I never direct, says Chandan Arora
  • For Eeshit Narain, it all started over a cup of tea…
  • I love the modern version of my script: Kamna Chandra
  • It was very personal for me, admits Ghazal Dhaliwal